The Borgia Pope's Unsolved Family Murder

The Borgias are the most infamous family in the history of the Catholic Church — a dynasty synonymous with corruption, poison, and murder at the very heart of the Vatican. And their most notorious crime is one they may have committed against themselves: an unsolved murder that has haunted history for over five hundred years, with the finger of suspicion pointing straight at the pope’s own children.

The family: At the centre of it sat Rodrigo Borgia, who in 1492 bought his way onto the throne of St. Peter and became Pope Alexander VI — arguably the most scandalous pope who ever lived. He was a pope with a mistress and a brood of illegitimate children whom he openly acknowledged and shamelessly promoted. Chief among them were his sons Cesare and Juan, and his daughter, the famous Lucrezia.

And of all his children, the pope had a clear favourite: Juan Borgia, the Duke of Gandia. Alexander doted on him, showered him with titles, lands, and honours, and made him captain-general of the papal armies — the commander of the Church’s soldiers. This blatant favouritism created a savage rivalry, above all with Juan’s brother Cesare. Cesare was brilliant, ruthless, and ambitious — and he had been forced into a career in the Church, made a cardinal, when what he truly craved was the military glory and power being lavished on his brother instead. Cesare wanted Juan’s life. And there were darker rumours too, of both brothers competing for the same woman — Sancha of Aragon, the wife of their own younger brother.

THE HORROR — the murder: On the night of the 14th of June 1497, the Borgia family gathered for dinner at the villa of Vannozza, the mother of the pope’s children, in the countryside near Rome. Juan was there, and so was Cesare, and their siblings. It was, by all accounts, a warm family evening.

Afterward, Juan rode off into the Roman night. He told his companions he was going to seek his own pleasures, and he peeled away with a single masked servant. It wasn’t unusual — Juan was known for carousing through the city after dark. He rode into the streets of Rome and vanished.

He never came home.

The next morning, his family grew alarmed. Then Juan’s horse returned — alone, without its rider, with one of its stirrups cut. His masked companion was found dying of stab wounds and could tell them nothing useful. Juan Borgia had disappeared off the face of the earth.

When the pope was told, he was gripped by terror. He ordered the city searched. And a boatman on the Tiber came forward with a chilling story: on the night of the murder, he’d watched from the river as men crept down to the water’s edge and threw something heavy off the back of a white horse into the Tiber — a body — and then threw stones to make sure it sank. Nobody had thought it worth reporting. Bodies in the Tiber, the boatman said with a shrug, were nothing new.

They dragged the river. And on the 16th of June, they pulled Juan Borgia’s body from the Tiber. He was still fully dressed — his fine clothes, his boots, his cloak — and, tellingly, his purse still held 30 gold ducats. This was no robbery. He had one wound to the throat, cutting it open, and eight more stab wounds across his head, body, and legs. Nine wounds in total. Juan had been ambushed, murdered, and dumped in the river by someone who wanted him dead, not his money.

THE MODERN RELIC Pope Alexander VI was utterly destroyed. The most powerful man in Christendom, the ruthless Borgia pope, collapsed into raw, howling grief. He shut himself in his room and reportedly wept and refused food and drink for days, his cries heard through the walls of the Vatican. Broken, he stood before the cardinals and swore that this catastrophe was God’s judgment on his own sins, and vowed to reform the corrupt Church and his own life.

Then he launched a massive, furious investigation to hunt down his son’s killers.

And a week later, abruptly, without explanation, he called the whole investigation off.

That sudden stop is the heart of the mystery. Why would a father consumed by grief, who had sworn to find his son’s murderers, simply stop — after a week? The most sinister interpretation, whispered then and argued ever since, is the one that has stuck: that Alexander stopped because he had discovered the killer’s identity, and it was too horrifying to pursue. That the murderer was inside his own family. Suspicion fell, above all, on Cesare Borgia — the jealous brother, who was soon after freed from his hated cardinal’s robes to become the very warlord-prince he’d always wanted to be, taking the military glory that had died with Juan. Others blamed the younger brother, Gioffre, over the shared mistress. And the Borgias had powerful outside enemies, the Orsini family, with plenty of motive too.

The truth was never established. It remains, five centuries later, one of history’s great unsolved murders. And the promised reformation of the Church? Alexander’s grief faded, and the vow of reform faded with it. Within months he was back to his old ways, and the Borgia corruption rolled on.

The relic is the record itself. The murder is documented in the Liber Notarum, the meticulous official diary of the papal master of ceremonies, Johann Burchard, who recorded the body’s recovery from the Tiber in cold, precise detail. That diary survives — the eyewitness account from inside the Vatican of the day they pulled the pope’s favourite son out of the river with nine wounds in him. And the Tiber still runs through Rome, past the same banks where, on a June night in 1497, someone the Borgias may have shared a dinner table with a few hours earlier threw the duke’s body into the black water and stoned it under.

← Back to the archive