When Rome Staged Executions As Myth

Everyone knows the Romans threw people to the beasts. Almost nobody knows they turned the executions into plays.

The poet Martial attended the inaugural games of the Colosseum under Emperor Titus in 80 CE and recorded what he witnessed in a short book of epigrams known as the Liber Spectaculorum – the Book of Spectacles. He didn’t describe random killings. He described carefully staged mythological re‑enactments in which condemned prisoners were costumed, given props, and forced to act out myths that ended in their real deaths.

The audience watched murder performed as narrative theatre.

The Horror

In one epigram, Martial describes a condemned man presented as Orpheus, the legendary musician whose song charmed wild animals. The man enters the arena dressed in Orpheus‑like costume, carrying a lyre. Harmless animals – deer, birds, smaller creatures – are released first and wander around him, creating the illusion that the myth is coming to life, that his “music” is pacifying the beasts.

The crowd watches in suspense, knowing the story. Then a bear is released. Instead of being charmed, it tears the “Orpheus” apart. Martial delights in the cruel irony: Orpheus, destroyed by the very creature he was supposed to master. The spectacle works as a twist ending because everyone in the stands already knows the original version.

In another poem, Martial describes the execution of a bandit named Laureolus, who according to earlier legend had been crucified and torn by animals. In the arena version, the condemned is hoisted on an actual cross and attacked by wild beasts as he hangs there. Martial writes that his mutilated body scarcely retained human shape, yet his mangled limbs still “lived” as they dripped with blood. The audience is watching both a criminal’s punishment and a live-action retelling of a myth.

Elsewhere, he alludes to a man fitted with wings and launched from a high platform as Icarus, only to fall to his death in the sand. The “role” comes with a built‑in ending.

After the Orpheus spectacle, Martial writes: “Whatever Rhodope is said to have watched on Orpheus’ stage, the arena, Caesar, displayed to you. The old‑time myth is now believed.”

That last line is the key to the whole system. “The old‑time myth is now believed.” The crowd is watching fiction become real. The condemned man is simultaneously a criminal being executed and a character fulfilling a script. The moment the bear kills “Orpheus,” both the man and the myth reach their climax. Death is not just punishment. It is the final act.

And it had to be timed. The arena day followed a programme. In the morning: animal hunts and displays (venationes). Around midday: executions of condemned criminals (damnatio), often staged as these mythological scenes. In the afternoon: gladiatorial combat. If the myth‑play ended too fast, the crowd felt cheated. If it dragged, it disrupted the day’s schedule. The Colosseum ran on a timetable. Death had a cue sheet.

The Modern Relic

The Colosseum still stands in Rome, its stone tiers open to tourists and school groups. Beneath the arena floor, the hypogeum — the underground honeycomb of corridors, animal cages, lifts, and trapdoors that made the shows possible — is now partly open to visitors.

You can walk through the backstage of the ancient arena where harmless animals were penned in one chamber, lethal predators in the next, scenery and machinery in another, all co‑ordinated by pulleys, winches, and trapdoors. From down there, you can look up and imagine the sand above, the painted sets, the man with the lyre, the bear waiting behind a gate, and a timetable pinned somewhere that said exactly when each would appear.

The audience is gone. The architecture of the illusion — the spaces that turned real death into myth and spectacle — is still in the stone.

← Back to the archive